Are Gifts Divided in an Ontario Divorce? Jewellery, Cars and Family Money
It’s nearing year-end, and the holidays are approaching. Gift-giving and shopping are starting to be on people’s minds – and on their “To Do” lists.
Gifts come in many sizes: Maybe it’s a new wristwatch from your spouse, or a brand-new set of golf clubs. Or maybe something much bigger: A car from your parents; a cheque from Grandma to help with the house; or an engagement ring under the Christmas tree.
But if your relationship ends, is that gift yours to keep, or does it get shared?
In the specific context of separation and divorce, in Ontario the answer depends mostly on three things:
- Who gave you the gift;
- Whether you were married when your relationship ended; and
- What you did with the gift afterwards.
Let’s untangle all that.
The Basic Rule: Who Gave the Gift?
In a recent Blog, we looked at Inherited Money in a Divorce. Non-monetary and other gifts follow many of the same rules, with a few twists of their own.
Let’s start with the basics: When a marriage ends in Ontario, each spouse’s “net family property” is calculated, and the spouse with more usually pays the other half the difference. For more on how that works, see our page on Property Division.
Under the Family Law Act, some property is left out of that calculation. That includes gifts you received during the marriage from a third person: This is someone other than your spouse, such as your parents, a grandparent or a friend.
But gifts from your spouse are different: They don’t qualify for the exclusion at all. A gift from your husband or wife simply becomes your property, and its value is counted in your net family property like anything else you own.
Here are some specific examples, to illustrate:
Cars
A car your spouse bought for you during the marriage is treated like any other gift between spouses. It’s your property, and it’s included.
On the other hand, a car your parents gave you after the wedding can be excluded, as long as you still have it, or can show what it was turned into. For example, if you traded it in toward a new one, you may be able to carry the exclusion over to the part of the new car’s value that came from the trade-in, if you can prove the details of that trade.
By the way, expect that your car will be valued at what it’s worth on the date you separated, not what you paid for it. In G.Y. v. C.Y., 2024 ONSC 1673, one spouse put a vehicle in at its purchase price from years earlier. The court pointed out that vehicles generally lose value, so it used book value instead.
Money From Parents Toward a House
This is where many people get caught off-guard. Even if your parents gave the money only to you, the exclusion from net family property is lost once the funds go into the matrimonial home (generally, the home you and your spouse were living in when you separated).
That’s because the Family Law Act specifically carves the matrimonial home out of the gift exclusion. In contrast, if you put the same money in an investment account in your own name, it can stay protected.
Parents’ money also raises a second question: Was it really a gift, or a loan? If it was a loan, it may be a debt that reduces your net family property instead. The courts will look for evidence of what your parents actually intended when they handed it over.
Be very careful about what gets signed. Mortgage lenders usually ask parents to sign a “gift letter” confirming that money toward the down payment is a gift that doesn’t have to be repaid. Courts take those letters seriously:
- In Y. v. C.Y., 2024 ONSC 1673, the husband argued that the down payment from his parents was really a loan and should be repaid to them when the home was sold. His mother admitted signing a gift letter that called the money “an outright gift with no repayment expected or implied.” The court found it was a gift, so the parents had no claim to the house. A claim to keep the money out of the property division as an excluded gift also failed. That is consistent with the rule that gifts put into the matrimonial home lose their protection.
- In a case called Lamacchia v. Carullo, 2022 ONSC 6366, a woman’s mother signed a similar acknowledgement for the lender, then testified at trial that the money had really been a loan that was still owed. The court treated that inconsistency as one of several reasons why the daughter’s evidence about her finances couldn’t be relied on.
If your parents mean the money as a loan, put it in writing, and don’t sign a document for the bank that says otherwise. If it’s a gift, make sure everyone’s story matches.
Jewellery
Jewellery can be expensive, so it often becomes the subject of post-separation disputes. Here is the breakdown:
- Marital gifts. If your former spouse gave you a necklace for your anniversary, it’s your property, and it’s included at its value on the date you separated.
- A family heirloom your mother gave you after you were married is simply considered a gift from a third person, and it can be excluded.
- Engagement rings. These are a special case: a ring given before the wedding was already yours on the date of marriage, so a different rule applies than the one for gifts received during the marriage.
For any jewellery that is included in your net family property, the court will ascribe a value to it, just like with any other asset. In this context, the value is usually what it would sell for on your separation date, which can be much less than what was paid. As the judge observed in Lamacchia v. Carullo, 2022 ONSC 6366, it is “quite likely” that a ring’s value after purchase is less than it actually cost the person buying it.
Broken Engagements: What If the Wedding Never Happens?
The topic of jewellery brings up an interesting side discussion: Engagement rings.
Ontario’s property-sharing rules apply to married spouses. If you were engaged but never married, different rules apply, and gifts made because of the wedding can sometimes be taken back.
The usual starting point is that an engagement ring is a gift that depends on the marriage actually taking place. If the wedding is called off, the ring generally goes back to the person who gave it. Under Ontario’s Marriage Act, it doesn’t matter whether the giver is the one who ended things.
But there’s no automatic rule. Courts look closely at the circumstances, and two recent Ontario decisions show how differently things can turn out.
In Cheng v. Qiu, 2023 ONSC 420, the couple ended their engagement, and the court ordered the woman to return the ring to the man. But it also had to consider how to treat the funds the man had given the woman for their planned wedding, as well as a cheque marked “Helping For Your Student Debt.” The court decided:
- Wedding money already spent on wedding purchases didn’t have to be repaid.
- The unspent balance did.
- The student-debt cheque was a loan to the woman, to be forgiven only once they married, so it had to be repaid.
In Lamacchia v. Carullo, 2022 ONSC 6366, the result was different. The couple was engaged and had a child together, but never married. The diamond ring was presented to the woman on Christmas morning, and the court accepted that it was meant to be her present for Christmas, Mother’s Day, her birthday and Valentine’s Day “for a long time.” It was found to be a true gift, not a conditional one, and she was allowed to keep it. That was so even though her former fiancé had asked for it back within a couple of months of their separation.
As these cases show, the outcome depends on the facts. So if you’re giving or receiving a ring over the holidays, keep in mind that when and how it’s given can matter later, if things don’t work out.
Why Tracing and Paperwork Are Important
The person claiming an exclusion has to prove it. If you can’t show where the money came from and where it went, the court may simply count it as ordinary family property.
Here are some practical tips on protecting gifted funds:
- Keep a record of the gift. A short note or letter from the giver confirming it was a gift to you alone is very helpful.
- Keep bank records showing the money arriving, and how it was used.
- Hold gifted money in an account in your name only, rather than mixing it into joint accounts.
- If you use the gift to buy something else, keep the paper trail. The law lets you “trace” a gift into what it was used to buy, except for the matrimonial home.
- Ask the giver about income. Interest or dividends earned on a gift are excluded only if the giver expressly said so.
- Consider a marriage contract. If keeping a gift separate matters to you, especially money toward a home, a domestic contract can protect it.
We Can Help
If you are separated and are wondering what happens to a ring, a car, or you’re the funds your parents gave you, give our offices a call. We can help you sort out what’s yours to keep, and what has to be shared.